Evolutionary models and biblical creation models make very different predictions about the likelihood of life, and especially intelligent life, elsewhere in the universe. Evolutionary models generally predict that life, and probably intelligent life, is relatively common in the universe, while creation models generally predict that we are alone in the universe. Three lines of evidence—the Fermi paradox, SETI, and the search for extrasolar planets—provide evidence to reach a conclusion on the matter. The evidence thus far greatly favors the creationary prediction and contradicts the evolutionary prediction.