I previously showed that James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) data were inconsistent with the standard model of cosmology (the big bang and galaxy evolution) but align well with a much simpler model in which galaxies move through a non-expanding metric (Lisle 2024). However, Barnes (2024) has alleged that the standard model of cosmology is consistent with estimated galaxy sizes based on JWST observations. We show here that the particular model advocated by Barnes was already disproved years ago on the basis of mass estimates and observed luminosities of galaxies in JWST deep field data. Furthermore, the sizes of galaxies in his model do not fit the data as well as the creation-based Doppler model. Thus, the Doppler model is currently the only cosmological model that is consistent with both angular size and luminosity data from JWST observations, and it alone passes the Tolman test.