Previously, I wrote a paper exposing some of the numerous scientific, logical, theological, and factual errors in the writings of Randy Guliuzza. Jean Lightner has commented on my paper, claiming that Guliuzza no longer denies natural selection, which is merely one of the errors I had pointed out previously. However, my paper was criticizing what Guliuzza has publicly written in which he indeed denies the reality of natural selection: a claim that he has never publicly retracted. Lightner also speculates on the motivations of those who deny Guliuzza's claims. Such speculations are logically irrelevant to Guliuzza's many errors of reasoning and fact. So, I suggest that Lightner's comments strengthen the claims of my original paper.