This article challenges the scientific validity of the widely accepted Big Bang theory. The author argues the Big Bang contradicts fundamental principles such as Einstein's special relativity and the conservation of mass-energy. St. Peter proposes an alternative model where the primordial fireball would collapse inward due to gravity, forming a black hole, rather than expanding outward. Ultimately, the author concludes the Big Bang lacks observational support, relies on circular reasoning, and fails to meet the criteria of a testable scientific hypothesis.