CRS Quarterly Research Database

Is Bacterial Resistance to Antibiotics an Appropriate Example of Evolutionary Change?

Anderson, Kevin L. (2005) Is Bacterial Resistance to Antibiotics an Appropriate Example of Evolutionary Change? Creation Research Society Quarterly, 41 (4): 4.

[thumbnail of Is Bacterial Resistance to Antibiotics an Appropriate Example of Evolutionary Change?.pdf]
Preview
PDF
Is Bacterial Resistance to Antibiotics an Appropriate Example of Evolutionary Change?.pdf

Download (282kB) | Preview

Abstract

Evolutionists frequently point to the development of antibiotic resistance by bacteria as a demonstration of evolutionary change. However, molecular analysis of the genetic events that lead to antibiotic resistance do not support this common assumption. Many bacteria become resistant by acquiring genes from plasmids or transposons via horizontal gene transfer. Horizontal transfer, though, does not account for the origin of resistance genes, only their spread among bacteria. Mutations, on the other hand, can potentially account for the origin of antibiotic resistance within the bacterial world, but involve mutational processes that are contrary to the predictions of evolution. Instead, such mutations consistently reduce or eliminate the function of transport proteins or porins, protein binding affinities, enzyme activities, the proton motive force, or regulatory control systems. While such mutations can be regarded as "beneficial," in that they increase the survival rate of bacteria in the presence of the antibiotic, they involve mutational processes that do not provide a genetic mechanism for common "descent with modification." Also, some "relative fitness" cost is often associated with such mutations, although reversion mutations may eventually recover most, if not all, of this cost for some bacteria. A true biological cost does occur, however, in the loss of pre-existing cellular systems or functions. Such loss of cellular activity cannot legitimately be offered as a genetic means of demonstrating evolution.

Item Type: Article
Subjects: Q Science (General) > QE Geology > QE103 Grand Canyon
Q Science (General) > QH Natural History. Biology > QH359 Biological Evolution
Depositing User: Admin
Date Deposited: 18 Mar 2025 21:44
Last Modified: 18 Mar 2025 21:44
URI: https://crsq.creationresearch.org/id/eprint/989

Actions (login required)

View Item
View Item